GeorgeWallace

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Wednesday, December 26, 2012

Worth the paper it's printed on

Posted on 5:00 AM by Unknown
A well regulated militia, being necessary to the security of a free state, the right of the people to keep and bear arms, shall not be infringed. -- 2nd Amendment

The right of the people to be secure in their persons, houses, papers, and effects, against unreasonable searches and seizures, shall not be violated, and no warrants shall issue, but upon probable cause, supported by oath or affirmation, and particularly describing the place to be searched, and the persons or things to be seized. -- 4th Amendment
For the most ardent gun rights advocates out there, the language of the 2nd Amendment is sacrosanct. Of course the qualifying clause before the comma is often brushed off as if it didn't exist.

We look back now at the Constitution and Bill of Rights as the great blueprints of our nation. At the time the Constitution was adopted, however, there were a multitude of voices arguing that the plan laid out in that document would only serve to enslave farmers and other agrarian interests. That's why we have two house of Congress - one represented the voice of the people and other represented the voice of the states. It's the reason the Electoral College was created - to ensure that the voters of just a few of the larger states could dictate who served as president. (The irony, of course, is that we have just the opposite situation today where the voters of a few states hold the rest of the nation hostage on Election Day.)

The agrarian interests were not in favor of a strong centralized government. They believed that only favored the monied interests in the larger states. One thing they really feared was the creation of a federal army. The 2nd Amendment was designed to sway those critics by leaving the defense of the republic to the state militias.

And, in order to have state militias capable of defending the republic against an expected attack from the English, folks needed to have guns.

Now that we have a professional army, the original rationale for the 2nd Amendment no longer exists.

If one wants to argue that the words of the 2nd Amendment are absolute, I can only show you the words in the 4th Amendment as proof that nothing in the Bill of Rights is absolute.

The 4th Amendment, despite its clear prohibition against unreasonable search and seizure and the warrant requirement has been honored far more in the breach than in the observance over the history of the republic. Most of the "reinterpretation" of the 4th Amendment has been the result of judges seeing cases in which someone either did something bad or had something bad and, but for a warrantless search, would have gotten away. Supreme Court justices, instead of reading the 4th Amendment and applying its words, adopted a results-oriented approach and looked for ways to get around the warrant requirement.

Over the years the Court has redefined "persons, houses, papers and effects" and created a mythical "reasonable expectation of privacy" test out of whole cloth. Courts have redefined "searches" and "seizures" in such a way that a person can be handcuffed in the back of a police car and not be considered seized and a pat down for weapons isn't considered a search. The word "unreasonable" has apparently been deleted from the English language and probable cause has become so watered down that stops are justified because an officer thinks someone may have violated the law.

Once upon a time we had a right to be left alone by the state, today you can get tased if you don't stop to answer questions. 

Maybe it helps that gun holders and makers have a very powerful lobby behind them with lots of money to throw around while victims of warrantless searches tend to be convicted criminals without a lot of cash.
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Posted in 2nd Amendment, 4th Amendment, Bill of Rights, handguns, search warrant, US Constitution | No comments
Newer Post Older Post Home

0 comments:

Post a Comment

Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

Popular Posts

  • Book review - The Fall of the House of Dixie
    The War Between the States. The War of Northern Aggression. The Civil War. No matter how you slice it, no matter what you call it, one thing...
  • School district climbs in bed with oil industry
    What a surprise to find, on my way back from lunch, that HISD's new Energy Institute High School is practically just around the corner ...
  • False equation
    In his latest shot at the defense bar, Grits for Breakfast seems to be making the argument that everyone should ignore the defense bar's...
  • How many innocent men must die?
    You know it's happened. We all know it's happened. We all try to pretend that there is no way it could happen. But that's just a...
  • History doesn't have to repeat itself to create a farce
    farce     [ fahrs ]   noun,   verb,   farced,   farc·ing. noun 1. a   light,   humorous   play   in   which   the   plot   depends   upon   ...
  • Book review: The Impeachment of Abraham Lincoln
    Ever play "what if?" Sure you have. What if the referee had ruled that Mike Renfro caught that ball in the end zone against the St...
  • Summer forecast - rolling blackouts?
    And once again it's time for our annual look at why our reverence with the concepts of free markets is misguided. Back when Texas deregu...
  • On being held up at the bank
    Update: I suppose I should first apologize for blaming this mess on Bank of America since, as I realized on my drive to court this morning, ...
  • Correct me if I'm wrong
    As I drove back in the rain from South Texas the other day I was listening to Talk of the Nation  on NPR. If you haven't tuned in, it...
  • Now for something completely different...
    What you are about to see (H/T NPR) is three years of the sun's life compressed into three minutes. NASA took two pictures a day of the ...

Categories

  • 14th Amendment (1)
  • 1st Amendment (11)
  • 2nd Amendment (2)
  • 4th Amendment (35)
  • 5th Amendment (1)
  • 6th Amendment (1)
  • 8th Amendment (5)
  • abortion (1)
  • addiction (3)
  • airlines (1)
  • alcohol concentration (8)
  • Andy Griffith (1)
  • Annise Parker (3)
  • Anthony Graves (1)
  • Anthony Kennedy (1)
  • Antonin Scalia (1)
  • Arizona (1)
  • asset forfeiture (1)
  • Austin Police Department (2)
  • automobile racing (1)
  • barbecue (1)
  • baseball (23)
  • basketball (2)
  • Bill Clinton (1)
  • Bill of Rights (4)
  • blogs (1)
  • blood test (6)
  • bombing (1)
  • bonds (1)
  • Brad Hart (1)
  • Bradley Manning (7)
  • Brady v. Maryland (3)
  • breath test (6)
  • Brett Ligon (1)
  • California (1)
  • Cameron County (1)
  • Cameron Willingham (1)
  • capital punishment (77)
  • Chicago (1)
  • Chile (1)
  • Chris Kyle (1)
  • Christoper Dupuy (9)
  • CIA (2)
  • civil liberties (3)
  • civil rights (1)
  • Civil War (1)
  • Clarence Thomas (1)
  • coercion (1)
  • college football (5)
  • Conroe (1)
  • controlled substance (1)
  • corruption (1)
  • court appointments (2)
  • court martial (1)
  • Court of Criminal Appeals (1)
  • courts (1)
  • crime and punishment (10)
  • crime labs (3)
  • criminal justice (43)
  • criminal procedure (6)
  • cycling (1)
  • Darrell Royal (1)
  • David Dewhurst (1)
  • DEA (1)
  • deadly weapon (1)
  • death penalty (78)
  • Declaration of Independence (4)
  • democracy (6)
  • developers (1)
  • discovery (8)
  • discrimination (1)
  • dissent (3)
  • DIVERT (2)
  • DNA (1)
  • domestic assault (1)
  • domestic surveillance (5)
  • driverless cars (1)
  • drones (2)
  • drought (1)
  • drug laws (3)
  • drug possession (3)
  • drugs (5)
  • drunk driving (26)
  • due process (10)
  • DWI (29)
  • economics (32)
  • education (7)
  • Egypt (2)
  • election (7)
  • Elizabeth Coker (1)
  • England (1)
  • entrapment (2)
  • environment (3)
  • equal protection (3)
  • Eric Holder (2)
  • espionage (2)
  • ethics (27)
  • European Union (1)
  • evidence (1)
  • execution (77)
  • exoneration (3)
  • expert testimony (1)
  • Facebook (1)
  • false confessions (1)
  • Fayette County (1)
  • FBI (3)
  • federal budget (1)
  • federal crimes (4)
  • federal judges (1)
  • federalism (1)
  • field sobriety tests (1)
  • First Amendment (1)
  • FISA (1)
  • football (1)
  • forensics (4)
  • France (1)
  • fraud (1)
  • freedom of expression (5)
  • Galveston County (11)
  • George Bush (1)
  • George McGovern (1)
  • George W. Bush (8)
  • George Zimmerman (1)
  • Gideon v. Wainwright (2)
  • Google (1)
  • Gov. Rick Perry (6)
  • Greece (2)
  • Greg Gladden (1)
  • Guantanamo (4)
  • Guatemala (1)
  • handguns (6)
  • Harris County (10)
  • Harris County courts (17)
  • Harris County DA's Office (15)
  • Harris County Democratic Party (1)
  • Harris County Jail (1)
  • Harris County Sheriff's Office (3)
  • HCCLA (3)
  • healthcare (2)
  • HISD (1)
  • history (2)
  • homeland security (1)
  • homeless (1)
  • Houston (7)
  • Houston municipal courts (3)
  • Houston Museum of Natural Science (1)
  • Houston Police Department (8)
  • HPD (1)
  • human rights (12)
  • humor (1)
  • ignition interlock (1)
  • immigration (3)
  • incentives (1)
  • indigent defense (6)
  • innocence (1)
  • internet (1)
  • intoxication manslaughter (1)
  • intoxilyzer (4)
  • Iran (2)
  • Iraq (1)
  • Italy (1)
  • Jackson County (1)
  • Japan (1)
  • jazz (1)
  • Jerry Sandusky (1)
  • John Boehner (2)
  • John Bradley (1)
  • John Kiriakou (1)
  • John Lewis (1)
  • journalism (1)
  • Judge Bill Harmon (1)
  • Judge David Hittner (1)
  • Judge John Phillips (1)
  • Judge Kelly Case (1)
  • Judge Kevin Fine (1)
  • Judge Mike Fields (2)
  • Judge Reece Rondon (1)
  • Judge Susan Criss (1)
  • Julian Assange (2)
  • junk science (6)
  • jurors (2)
  • jury (1)
  • Justice of the Peace (2)
  • juvenile law (1)
  • juveniles (6)
  • Ken Anderson (1)
  • KPFT (1)
  • labor (3)
  • Lance Armstrong (2)
  • Larry Swearingen (1)
  • Latin America (1)
  • law school (2)
  • Liberty County (1)
  • limited government (1)
  • Lloyd Oliver (3)
  • logic (1)
  • Longhorns (4)
  • Lynne Stewart (1)
  • Mack Brown (1)
  • Mali (1)
  • Manny Diaz (1)
  • marijuana (3)
  • marketing (2)
  • Martin Luther King (2)
  • mathematics (2)
  • medicine (1)
  • mental illness (6)
  • Mesquite (1)
  • METRO (2)
  • Mexico (1)
  • Michael Morton (2)
  • Middle East (3)
  • Mike Anderson (7)
  • military coup (1)
  • Mitt Romney (3)
  • Montgomery County (2)
  • Montgomery County DA's Office (2)
  • municipal court (1)
  • murder (5)
  • NASCAR (3)
  • National Lawyers Guild (1)
  • NATO (1)
  • NCAA (1)
  • New York (1)
  • Newt Gingrich (1)
  • NHTSA (2)
  • No Refusal Weekend (2)
  • Nobel Prize (1)
  • NSA (2)
  • official oppression (1)
  • oil (3)
  • Olympics (1)
  • parking (1)
  • Pat Lykos (4)
  • Patriot Act (1)
  • Pearland (1)
  • Penn State (1)
  • pentobarbital (1)
  • personal bonds (1)
  • philosophy (2)
  • Pine Shadows (1)
  • poker (1)
  • police brutality (4)
  • police tactics (3)
  • politics (50)
  • Polk County (1)
  • President Obama (25)
  • presumption of innocence (2)
  • pretrial diversion (2)
  • prison (4)
  • privacy (14)
  • prosecutorial misconduct (2)
  • psychiatry (1)
  • psychology (1)
  • public defender's office (1)
  • punishment (2)
  • Pussy Riot (1)
  • R. Allen Stanford (1)
  • racism (4)
  • rape (1)
  • religion (7)
  • revenge (1)
  • Roger Clemens (1)
  • rule of law (1)
  • running (3)
  • Russia (1)
  • same-sex marriage (2)
  • schools (2)
  • science (6)
  • scientific evidence (1)
  • search warrant (8)
  • sentencing (5)
  • Sharon Keller (1)
  • smuggling (1)
  • soccer (3)
  • social media (4)
  • social security (1)
  • South Africa (2)
  • Spring Branch (1)
  • surcharges (1)
  • Syria (2)
  • taser (2)
  • technology (1)
  • television (1)
  • Texas (4)
  • Texas Constitution (3)
  • Texas DPS (5)
  • Texas Supreme Court (2)
  • Thane Rosenbaum (1)
  • The Gambia (1)
  • torture (9)
  • Tour de France (2)
  • traffic (1)
  • traffic court (3)
  • Trayvon Martin (1)
  • trial preparation (2)
  • trial tactics (10)
  • Troy Anthony Davis (1)
  • TSA (3)
  • Twitter (1)
  • University of Texas (2)
  • US Constitution (7)
  • US Supreme Court (6)
  • Victoria County (1)
  • Vietnam (1)
  • violence (1)
  • Visa (1)
  • voir dire (3)
  • voting (3)
  • war (7)
  • war crimes (6)
  • war on terrorism (24)
  • Washington (1)
  • Wells Fargo (2)
  • white collar crime (1)
  • Wikileaks (6)
  • Williamson County (1)
  • writ of habeas corpus (1)

Blog Archive

  • ►  2013 (242)
    • ►  September (11)
    • ►  August (26)
    • ►  July (27)
    • ►  June (22)
    • ►  May (33)
    • ►  April (32)
    • ►  March (29)
    • ►  February (29)
    • ►  January (33)
  • ▼  2012 (258)
    • ▼  December (32)
      • (In)justice of the peace
      • Fiscal cliff? What fiscal cliff?
      • Here's another bad idea
      • Thinking twice before uttering that big number
      • Book review: The (honest) truth about dishonesty
      • Worth the paper it's printed on
      • Christmas thoughts
      • On ritual, superstition and subjugation
      • It's time to shuffle up and deal, Mr. President
      • What's to blame for our addiction to guns?
      • Time for the annual crackdown on the Fourth Amendment
      • Big brother on the couch
      • Texas DPS sued over roadside cavity search
      • Unreality television
      • Merging courts a bad idea
      • The rich really are different from the rest of us
      • I've got a theory about that
      • If not now, when?
      • The (show) trial of the century
      • Tanks for the memories
      • NTSB calls for mandatory ignition interlocks
      • Peace is in the eye of the beholder
      • He's out for a scalp
      • Separated at birth?
      • Failing our children
      • Flawging at straws
      • Military ousts judge in court martial
      • Take five, Dave
      • Faking it until you make it
      • Foreclosing on Argentina
      • The power of teamwork
      • A slight change in plans
    • ►  November (32)
    • ►  October (35)
    • ►  September (30)
    • ►  August (37)
    • ►  July (36)
    • ►  June (28)
    • ►  May (28)
Powered by Blogger.

About Me

Unknown
View my complete profile